Ok so there has been a lot of talk about toxic chemicals in nail polish. Established brands have changed their formulas to be free of these chemicals which raises a lot of questions. What are they? What do they do? Why are they so bad? Are polishes just as good without them? Who makes polishes free of the Big 3? I'm going to try and answer those questions here.
What are the Big 3 toxic chemicals?
The chemicals we're talking about are Dibutyl Phthalate (DBP), Formaldehyde and Toluene.
What do they do?
Dibutyl Phthalate (DBP) is a plasticiser to prevent chips and cracks. DBP is an oily liquid that is soluble in fat and slightly soluble in water. It is not very volatile so it does not evaporate readily into the atmosphere.
Over 75% of DBP is used as a plasticiser in polymers such as PVC, 14% is used in adhesives, 7% in printing inks and 3% in other miscellaneous uses, including sealants and grouting agents used in construction as well as consumer products such as cosmetics.
http://www.greenfacts.org/glossary/def/DBP-dibutyl-phthalate.htm
Formaldehyde does not exist in nail polish. It is used in some nail hardeners but not in the actual polish. A resin, tosylamide/formaldehyde resin, makes the polish tough and resilient. While the resin is manufactured from formaldehyde, once the product becomes a resin, the formaldehyde is chemically changed and essentially no longer present. So while formaldehyde is grouped in with toluene and DBP in marketing statements and considered one of the Big 3, it isn't actually an issue unless you have a reaction to the formaldehyde resin.
The bottom line, you should be aware of formaldehyde in your treatment products, not polish.
Toluene (methylbenzene, toluol, phenylmethane) is a solvent that makes the polish easy to apply. It is an aromatic hydrocarbon commonly used as an industrial solvent for the manufacturing of paints, chemicals, pharmaceuticals, and rubber.
Toluene is found in gasoline, acrylic paints, varnishes, lacquers, paint thinners, adhesives, glues, rubber cement, airplane glue, and shoe polish. At room temperature, toluene is a colorless, sweet smelling, volatile liquid.
http://www.emedicine.com/emerg/topic594.htm
Why are they bad?
I'm not convinced that they are bad. I really think this is something each person should decide for themselves. There are risks and effects caused by exposure to each of these chemicals. But, whether or not limited exposure to polish will actually result in those effects is yet to be determined. I don't feel it is my place to make that call so I choose to present you with the info I've found so you can make up your own mind.
US FDA Office of Cosmetics and Color's report on Using Nail Products
Professional Beauty Association's Facts About Salon Nail Polish Products for Consumers
Campaign for Safe Cosmetics
Environmental Working Group's report The Dangers Of Phthalates Industry Spin vs. Fact
California Proposition 65
Are Polishes Just As Good Without Them?
The not so fun answer is, it depends. While some brands have been Big 3 free for years and have top notch formulas, some of the brands jumping on the band wagon don't have it quite right yet. The best thing I can tell you is to experiment. I've noticed that with OPI's newest collection, Night Brights, it's hit or miss.
Who makes polishes free of the Big 3?
Avon, Butter London, Dashing Diva "Extra Virgin", HoneyBee Gardens, Lippmann Collection (newer collections), NailTini, NARS (new formula), Nocti, Nubar, OPI (Australia collection & newer), Revlon, Sally Hansen, Vinyl Deborah Lippmann, Zoya
DBP free but still contain toluene: Creative Nail Design, Misa, Orly
Are there brands I left out? Please email me or post a comment, I want to keep this listing as accurate as possible. Thank you!


12 comments:
I'm glad to hear that Sally Hansen polishes are "Big 3" free. I just tried their No Chip 10 Day polish, and I love it--it's super-smooth to apply and dries streak-free. And it does last an awfully long time, though not quite 10 days--but that's okay since I always want to change my polish before then anyway!
Thank you for this enlightening coverage of the companies who are proactively trying to keep their customers safer.
I'd rather use something that doesn't have petrochemicals or potentially harmful irritants, than something that does. You never know what the long term effects of exposure can be, or if any genetic mutations, or excessive built up inflamation is being caused -- they don't necessarily do much research on the effects of all the abuses we put our body through on a daily basis.
By the way I'm so hooked on your blog, you're so fun to read, and provide the best and most updated info on nail care trends and colors. I've searched high and low and finally find your blog for all the info I was looking for on nails and trends. Thank you!!
Keep up the awesome job!
-J
L'Oreal ("Pro Manicure" line - not sure about others) is free of all three. I'd love to know if Rimmel polishes are free of these chemicals, too!
Rimmel polishes are also free of all the nasties. I emailed Coty (Rimmel's parent brand) to find out. Here's the response I got:
"All RIMMEL® nail enamels are free of dibutyl phthalate (DBP), toluene, formaldehyde, and formaldehyde resin, with the exception of RIMMEL® Nail Rescue, which contains trace amounts of formaldehyde and formaldehyde resin."
Yay!
Glad to see a fellow beauty blogger informing everyone about DBP, Formaldehyde and Toluene in nailpolish. Great to read the info on which brands are free of these chemicals! Comes in handy, especially for the pregnant crowd.
Check out my post on the subject:
On my Beauy Blog, Raging Rouge. LOVE your blog, BTW!
another one that is free of all 3 is Sparitual......72 colors and treatments + they are also vegan.
Please add Color Club to your list, their polishes are free of the big 3 as well.
It's wonderful to see so many people paying attention to these chemicals and their inclusion into products that we use every day. I am a nail technician, and I inform my clients that the nails are about 100 times more absorbent than skin, so be careful what you put on them! I use Spa Ritual exclusively, which is from the UK. (the EU is far ahead of the US in banning chemicals and have banned the "Big 3") DBP in particular is a reproductive system toxin and has recently been linked to birth defects. Spa Ritual has eliminated these 3, and in place of it have incorporated rubber polymers. My pedi clients typically add 2 weeks onto the pedicure when they use Spa Ritual, rebooking in 6 wks instead of 4! They are also vegan and have lots of fantastic colors. I would suggest this line to anyone looking to eliminate these toxins from their beauty routine!
The National Research Council is currently doing a study on the Phthalates and it's possible health risks. I'll wait for the verdict, but I don't think it will be good.
I see you mentioned Sally Hansen when listing the polishes that don't have the Big 3. I'm allergic to formaldehyde, so I always check and most Sally Hansen polishes do have formaldehyde resin in them. I have even emailed them about it but received not response.
Zoya and Sparitual are 2 major brands that don't use the big 3!
I believe Adoree nail polish also big 3 free. I don't see those big 3 words in the ingredients list. Check out the detail here: http://www.esthersnc.com/adoree.html.
Post a Comment